How to Challenge Your Home Appraisal

Step-By-Step Guide

How to Challenge Your Home Appraisal (Step-by-Step Guide)

If your home appraisal came in lower than expected, you’re not stuck with it. Whether you’re buying, refinancing, removing PMI, or disputing a property tax assessment, there are legitimate ways to challenge a home appraisal—and many people succeed when they approach it with evidence, not emotion.

This guide explains the best strategies to appeal an appraisal, how a Reconsideration of Value (ROV) works, what evidence actually matters, common mistakes to avoid, and how Vallink can help you move quickly with a structured appraisal review.

Why Home Appraisals Come in Low

Appraisals are opinions of value based on data and judgment. Most appraisers do good work, but low appraisals happen for reasons like:

  • Inappropriate comparable sales (wrong neighborhood, wrong market segment, inferior location)

  • Missed or outdated comps (better comps available but not used)

  • Incorrect property data (gross living area, room count, basement finish, lot size, condition)

  • Insufficient adjustments for upgrades, quality, views, acreage, or amenities

  • Market trend errors (values rising, but appraisal anchored to older sales)

  • Condition misrating (renovations not reflected; “average” when it’s “good/excellent”)

  • Functional differences ignored (layout, bedroom/bath utility, garage, finished space)

  • Neighborhood analysis issues (demand/supply, marketing time, price trends not supported)

A low appraisal can be frustrating, but it’s also often fixable—if you can show the problem clearly.

The Two Main Ways to Challenge an Appraisal

1) Reconsideration of Value (ROV) — Mortgage Appraisals

A Reconsideration of Value is a formal request asking the lender (or appraisal management company) to reconsider the appraised value due to errors or overlooked information.

This is commonly used for:

  • Conventional loans (often sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac)

  • Purchases and refinances

  • PMI removal disputes (varies by lender policy)

Key point: You typically can’t contact the appraiser directly. You submit evidence through the lender, and the lender/AMC decides whether to send it back to the appraiser.

2) Tax Assessment Appeal — County/City Property Taxes

If your assessment is too high, you can usually appeal through your assessor’s office or a board of review. The rules vary by county/state, but the winning formula is the same:

  • Identify factual errors (square footage, land size, condition, features)

  • Provide comparable sales or a credible valuation basis

  • Follow the local procedure and deadlines precisely

What Actually Works When You Appeal an Appraisal

Start with the “Hard Errors” (These Win Fast)

Before debating comps, confirm basic facts. Mistakes here can undermine the entire appraisal:

  • Gross living area (GLA) and finished basement area

  • Bedroom/bath count

  • Lot size / acreage

  • View, waterfront, corner lot, busy road influence

  • Quality/condition rating

  • Renovation dates and scope

  • HOA fees or restrictions

  • Zoning, highest and best use, or legal nonconformity

If you can prove a factual error, you’re not arguing opinion—you’re correcting the record.

Then Attack the Comparable Sales (Where Value Often Moves)

Most appraisal disputes succeed because of comp selection. Strong ROVs focus on:

  • Better comps (same neighborhood, similar style/quality, similar GLA, similar lot)

  • More recent comps (especially if prices are rising)

  • Competitive listings and pendings (sometimes accepted as support, even if not “closed”)

  • Missing upgrades (kitchen/baths, roof, HVAC, windows, flooring, additions)

  • Location differences (school district, walkability, noise, traffic, topography)

Pro tip: A strong challenge doesn’t dump 15 random comps. It submits 3–6 excellent comparables and explains why they’re superior.

Provide a Clean Upgrade/Repair Packet

Appraisers respond to documentation. Helpful items include:

  • A one-page upgrade summary (what, when, cost)

  • Receipts/invoices (major items)

  • Before/after photos

  • Contractor estimates for items that affect condition

  • Permit history (if available)

Even if cost doesn’t equal value, it supports condition/quality, and that affects adjustments.

Step-by-Step: How to Challenge Your Home Appraisal

Step 1: Get the Full Appraisal Report

Ask your lender for the complete report and read it carefully. Highlight:

  • Property description

  • Condition rating

  • Comp grid and adjustments

  • Neighborhood/market analysis

  • Reconciliation narrative

Step 2: Identify the Best “Attack Angle”

Most successful appraisal appeals fall into one (or more) of these buckets:

  • Factual errors

  • Comp selection problems

  • Adjustment problems

  • Condition/quality misclassification

  • Market trend misinterpretation

Step 3: Collect Evidence (Keep It Tight)

Build a clean packet:

  • 3–6 strong comps (closed sales preferred)

  • Photos or MLS sheets for comps (if available)

  • Short explanation for each comp (why it matches better)

  • Upgrade summary + receipts (if relevant)

  • Any factual corrections with proof

Step 4: Submit Through Your Lender (ROV) or Assessor (Taxes)

Follow the procedure exactly:

  • Use the lender’s ROV process (email portal, form, or LO submission)

  • Respect deadlines (tax appeals can be strict)

  • Stay professional—your tone matters

Step 5: Prepare for Outcomes

Possible results include:

  • No change (common)

  • Value revised upward (possible)

  • Appraiser adds an addendum or changes comps/adjustments

  • Second appraisal ordered (rare, but sometimes happens if quality issues are severe)

Common Mistakes That Kill Appraisal Challenges

Avoid these—because lenders see them every day:

  • Emotional arguments (“This is unfair” / “My neighbor said…”)

  • Using unrelated comps from different neighborhoods/markets

  • Submitting too many comps without clear reasoning

  • Focusing only on your contract price as proof

  • Trying to contact the appraiser directly (often prohibited)

  • Missing deadlines or submitting incomplete documentation

The goal is to make the reviewer think:
“This is specific, credible, and easy to verify.”

What If You Don’t Know What’s Wrong?

This is the real problem for most homeowners: you feel the appraisal is low, but you don’t know where the weaknesses are—or how to present them in a way that a lender will take seriously.

That’s exactly what Vallink is built for.

Get a Vallink Appraisal Review in Under an Hour

Vallink provides an instant, structured appraisal review designed to help you:

  • Challenge your home appraisal

  • Build a cleaner ROV submission

  • Identify factual inconsistencies and weak support

  • Focus your evidence on what matters most

How it works

1. Upload your appraisal
2. Checkout
3. Receive your review by email within an hour

Why Vallink helps

  • Fast enough to meet real-world deadlines

  • Organized into clear, actionable findings

  • Designed to support appraisal appeals and ROV packages

  • Saves you hours of confusion and trial-and-error

FAQ: Challenging a Home Appraisal

Can I challenge a home appraisal on a conventional loan?

Yes—typically through a Reconsideration of Value (ROV) submitted to the lender/AMC. The process and success rates vary by lender.

How long does an ROV take?

Some lenders respond in a few days; others take longer. That’s why preparing a strong submission up front matters.

Will the appraiser change the value?

Sometimes, but it’s not guaranteed. The best chance is when there are clear errors or better comps that were overlooked.

Should I order a second appraisal?

Usually the lender decides. A second appraisal is uncommon unless there are serious issues with the original report.

Can Vallink guarantee an increase?

No. Vallink provides informational review content to support an appeal, but outcomes depend on the lender/assessor and the facts of the case.

Ready To Get Started?

Start New Request